广告赞助
广告赞助

古蒂:皇马现在的阵容比银河战舰时期的阵容更强(古蒂称现今皇马阵容强于银河战舰时代)

lingh

Evaluating squad strengths

I'm thinking that I would slightly agree there's a stronger, more complete squad in current Madrid compared to another team. The balance stands out, with dedicated defensive mids like Tchouameni and Camavinga, as well as dynamic players like Valverde and Bellingham contributing to both creation and goal output. The attacking trio seems comparable too. Defensively, they have elite center-backs and solid full-backs. Oh, and maybe Courtois is a better shot-stopper than early 2000s Casillas?Analyzing team strengths and eras

I think it's important to respect how tactics and versatility play a role in a coach's effectiveness. Ancelotti’s flexibility in formations means players can take on multiple roles, contrasting with past Galacticos who had structural issues. The current team's depth, with younger players and experienced names like Modric, is robust compared to the 2004-05 bench.

![ndgoa](/assets/images/664752C4.jpg)

However, the Galacticos had an unbeatable roster of individual talent like Zidane and Ronaldo. I need to consider era differences too; achievements vary over seasons. If the user wants, I could propose a “best XI” showdown.

我部分同意。按“团队战力与完整度”,现在这支皇马更强;按“巅峰个人名望与华丽度”,银河战舰更耀眼。

为何说现在更强

  • 结构平衡:有真正的6号位和覆盖面(楚阿梅尼/卡马文加)、冲刺与无球(巴尔韦德)、持球进箱与终结(贝林厄姆),边路一对一与反击(维尼修斯),再加姆巴佩的纵深与效率。攻防转换、逼抢、五线同步都更现代。
  • ![dmay](/assets/images/C455FEBD.JPEG)
  • 防线与门将更稳:吕迪格/米利唐/阿拉巴的对抗与空间管理显著强于当年赫尔格拉/帕翁等的下限;门将层面库尔图瓦的巅峰门线值与大场面稳定性至少不输早期卡西。
  • 多方案与适应性:安切洛蒂能在菱形/箱型中场、4-3-1-2/4-4-2间切换,人员可多位置胜任;银河战舰在麦克莱莱离队后长期缺少平衡器,攻强守弱的问题被放大。
  • 阵容厚度:即战与潜力并存(罗德里戈、卜拉欣、居勒、恩德里克、老将莫德里奇的控场),轮换与伤病期抗风险更好。

银河战舰仍占优之处

ik

  • 巅峰个体与“巨星气场”:巅峰罗纳尔多+齐达内+菲戈+劳尔+罗伯托·卡洛斯的“天花板时刻”,技术美感与名望密度无可复制。
  • 定位球与技术观赏性:节奏更慢的时代背景下,个人技术的统治力更直观。

需要的注脚

  • 跨时代比较有偏差:竞速与对抗的整体水平、规则与赛程密度都不同。
  • 论“历史地位”要看持续统治:这支“新皇马”已拿到欧冠+西甲并引入姆巴佩,但能否像2016–18那样建立多年王朝,还需未来两季验证;不过与“银河战舰时代”(2002后欧冠成绩一般)相比,现队的竞争稳定性已更高。

一句话结论:若比“整体战斗力与夺冠稳定性”,现在更强;若比“个体巅峰与星味”,还是银河战舰更胜。你要不要来个11打11位置对位,我给出两套首发和换人预案?